• 65 Posts
  • 565 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: February 10th, 2024

help-circle











  • SimpleX has some interesting ideas, but also some shortcomings for people who want a practical messaging service. For example:

    • It is funded by venture capital, which calls into question its longevity, and even if it does manage to stick around, suggests that it will be leveraged to exploit people once the user base is large enough.
    • Its queue servers delete messages if they are not delivered within a certain time frame (21 days by default). Good luck if you take a vacation off-grid for a few weeks.
    • No multi-device support. (This means a single account accessed concurrently from multiple independent devices.) The closest it comes is locally tethering a mobile device to a computer.
    • Establishing new contacts requires sharing a large link or QR code, which is not always convenient.
    • No support for group calls.

    I would not recommend it for talking to family members and people in general, which is what OP requested.



  • a compromised or hostile home server can still take over the room

    A compromised server could affect a denial of service attack against its users, of course. The attacker could do the same thing by simply turning off the server. That’s true on all platforms that use servers. A reasonable response would be to switch to a different server.

    That admin (or even a newly minted user) can then send events

    Exactly what events do you think would be dangerous?

    or listen on the conversations.

    No. End-to-end encryption ensures that only the intended endpoints can read the messages. Older Matrix clients have a setting to block the user from sending messages to unverified devices/sessions, in case they somehow don’t understand the meaning of a bright red warning icon. I think newer ones (e.g. Element X) enforce that mode; if you’re concerned about this, you could check for yourself, but…

    not everyone will pay attention to unverified warnings

    …unfortunately, there are no guarantees when trying to fix human behavior. If you need a messaging app to make it hard for your contacts to do something obviously foolish, then I suggest waiting until Matrix 2.0 is officially released and implemented in the clients. The beta versions of Element X, for example, look like everything is locked down to avoid human mistakes like the one you’re describing.






  • mox@lemmy.sdf.orgOPtoLinux@lemmy.worldUbuntu developer discussion moving to Matrix
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    6 days ago

    I like IRC, too, but I have to admit some of its mechanisms are annoying and not very good. (Nickserv for identity management, for example.)

    I don’t think IRC is as good as Matrix for decentralisation, either. If an IRC host network goes down or is taken over, it’s very disruptive to the communities using it, as we saw with the freenode fiasco.